fbpx

Green Leaf Air

by Rifat A. in Air Conditioning, Blog, Heating, HVAC Tips 0 comment

Beating the scorching summer heat is impossible without a good air conditioner. And whether you are thinking of installing a new HVAC system or just upgrading your existing one, finding the right air conditioner is difficult when there are hundreds of brands and models out there.

Trane and Carrier are two of the top brands in the HVAC industry, and their air conditioner units have proved themselves in terms of performance, efficiency, and quality. But choosing between the two brands can be quite difficult. So, to make the choice of air conditioner units easier for you, we have pieced together this Trane vs. Carrier guide. In this guide, we will discuss their features and compare these two brands.

 

Trane vs. Carrier

Trane

Carrier
SEER Rating Up to 22 with Several Options Limited options for 20+ SEER rating
Energy Efficiency 30-40% more savings 25% more savings
Manufactured In United States Mexico
Manufactured By Ingersoll Rand United Technologies Corporation
Compressors Trane’s own premium Climatuff compressor Copeland compressor manufactured by Emerson
Installation Process Moderately Complex that requires expert handling, ensuring a professional installation Easier Compared to Trane that can be handled by even a novice contractor, risking compromised installation
Parts Replacement Expensive and difficult to find or counterfeit, ensuring authenticity of parts Reasonably priced and easily available, making it easy to counterfeit
Maintenance & Repair Trane coils are well-built and last longer without needing repair or replacement Carrier units require frequent replacements as their coils wear out faster
Warranty 10 years on all parts and 12 years on the compressor Limited warranty of 10 years
Thermostat More Advanced ComfortLink II Infinity System with basic controls
Home Control & Compatibility Trane’s Nexia is compatible with both Google Home & Amazon Alexa Carrier’s Cor Smart Home is compatible with Amazon Alexa only
Humidity Control More sophisticated Comfort-R humidity control process

Infinity Touch with moderate control

 

 

Trane vs. Carrier – Comparison

While both Carrier and Trane are good quality air conditioners, comparing the two brands is essential to determine which is better than the other. Here, we will compare the features, performance, efficiency, warranty, etc., of both the air conditioners in this Carrier vs. Trane discussion.

·         Product Tiers

Trane manufactures air conditioners in three tiers, ranked as basic, better, and best. These ranks are selected based on the energy efficiency and other relative factors of the air conditioner unit. Similar to Trane, Carrier HVAC also produces three tiers of air conditioners.

·         SEER Rating

SEER rating in HVAC units refers to the maximum energy efficiency of the air conditioner. To ensure performance with maximum energy efficiency, it is advised to choose an air conditioner unit with a high SEER rating.

Units that come with a SEER rating of 14 or higher are categorized under good-quality air conditioners. Trane has several 22 SEER air conditioner and heat pump units, whereas Carrier only has a few units that exceed the 20+ SEER rating. Carrier also has a 26 SEER model, but the options are limited. On the other hand, Trane has many 20-22 SEER units to choose from.

·         Energy Efficiency

As the rising cost of electricity has started to put a dent in our wallets, finding an energy-efficient air conditioner is essential. Energy efficient units will require less amount of electricity than traditional air conditioners, allowing you to save energy. This energy saving will, in turn, help homeowners save money on electric bills.

If we talk about the energy efficiency of Trane and Carrier air conditioners, then the Trane AC offers an energy efficiency of 30 to 40 percent compared to traditional air conditioners. On the other hand, Carrier AC units ensure an energy efficiency of 25 percent in comparison to the previous generations of air conditioners.

·         Compressors

In an air conditioner, a good compressor is a must for satisfactory performance.  Trane manufacturers its own compressor, named Climatuff. This compressor ensures high quality and long-lasting performance. On the other hand, Carrier units use Copeland compressors manufactured by Emerson.

·         Manufacturing

All Trane products are manufactured in the United States by the multinational company Ingersoll Rand. And Carrier units are produced in Mexico by United Technologies Corporation.

·         Installation Process

Paying attention to the installation complexity of the air conditioners is essential. If the installation process is too complicated, there is a chance that the AC units will not be installed properly, and hence, the air conditioner will not be able to perform properly. This results in damage to the components and waste of electricity.

Both Trane AC and Carrier AC units come with a moderately complex installation process and quality. However, Carrier air conditioners are easier to install in comparison to Trane air conditioners. But that also means Trane units will require professional handling, ensuring no room for mistakes by pros.

·         Parts Replacement

Maintenance and replacement of air conditioner units are essential to ensure smooth and proper performance at all times. However, the cost and availability of the parts play a major role in the maintenance of the units.

The replacement parts for the Trane air conditioner are quite expensive and are a bit difficult to find. However, this helps the users to ensure the authenticity of the products. On the other hand, the Carrier AC parts can be found easily and are available at a reasonable cost.

·         Maintenance & Repair

Trane air conditioners are the way to go if you do not want to spend a lot of money on maintenance. The reason behind this is Carrier units require frequent replacements as their coils wear out faster. Trane air conditioners rarely require replacements, and their coils are not as vulnerable as Carrier air conditioners.

·         Warranty

Due to the high cost of the air conditioner units and parts, the warranty is an essential factor. Trane offers a warranty of 10 years on all parts of the unit and a warranty of 12 years on the compressor of the AC. However, Carrier AC comes with a limited warranty facility for 10 years.

·         Thermostat

Thermostat in air conditioners and heater units monitor and control the temperature. Both Trane and Carrier air conditioners are equipped with smart thermostats that can be controlled by iOS and Android. Trane uses ComfortLink II, and the Carrier air conditioner uses the Infinity, Cor thermostat.

·         Smart Home Control & Compatibility

Both Trane and Carrier are compatible with smart home appliances for easier control of the air conditioners and heating units. Trane is equipped with Nexia that connects to Google Home and Amazon Alexa, whereas Carrier’s Cor Smart Home is compatible with Alexa only.

·         Humidity Control

Both of these brands come with humidity control features that remove the extra humidity during the hot summer days. It makes the environment of your home more comfortable, even at high temperatures. Trane air conditioners use a more sophisticated Comfort-R humidity control, and Infinity Touch is used in Carrier units, which is not as advanced as Trane’s.

 

Trane AC vs. Carrier AC

Trane vs. Carrier
Trane vs. Carrier

 

Trane Vs. Carrier: Final Decision

Now that we have compared all the major factors between the Trane AC and Carrier AC, it is time to reach a conclusion.

After considering all the features, it is safe to conclude that Trane air conditioners are better in comparison to the Carrier air conditioners. We agree that Carrier AC units provide an advantage over Trane units in terms of maintenance and installation. But the Trane air conditioner units ensure a better performance in terms of warranty, SEER, and energy efficiency.

Rifat A.

HVAC Expert, Author & Mathematician...

0 thoughts on “Trane vs. Carrier – Which Air Conditioner Is Better?”

Leave a Reply